Essential Negotiation Skills: Limiting Cognitive Bias in Negotiation

Essential business negotiation strategies and tactics to create value at the bargaining table

By — on / Negotiation Skills

negotiation

A range of psychological biases can influence negotiators—many of which stem from an overreliance on intuition. These biases can undermine the success of integrative negotiation. Negotiators often assume they can easily recognize when it’s safe to trust their intuition and when a situation calls for more deliberate analysis. Unfortunately, such assumptions frequently turn out to be wrong.

In fact, most of us trust our intuition more than evidence suggests that we should.

Intuition and Reality in Negotiation

To explain why individuals don’t always think rationally or logically, Keith Stanovich of the University of Toronto and Richard F. West of James Madison University have distinguished between what they call System 1 and System 2 thought:

  • System 1 thought describes our intuition: quick, automatic, effortless, and influenced by emotion.
  • System 2 thought is slower, more conscious, effortful and logical.

We can all think of instances in which we acted rashly, relying on System 1 thoughts and emotions, as well as times when we carefully evaluated a situation using System 2 logic.

System 1 Versus System 2 Logic in Integrative Negotiation

Unfortunately, most people – especially busy managers and executives – fall back on System 1 thinking during their negotiations.

Reliance on intuition increases when a situation is complex and negotiators reach a state of cognitive overload. At such times, our ability to process information is pushed to the limit, and we naturally shift away from System 2 thought toward System 1 thought.

Clearly, a complete System 2 thought process is not necessary for every managerial decision or for every small negotiation you may face. When you’re negotiating with your coworkers over where to go for lunch, when you’re setting deadlines for low-priority tasks, or when you’re informally discussing items that you plan to revisit later in more detail, System 1 thought will be sufficient.

Four Strategies for More Rational Integrative Negotiation Approach

The following negotiation strategies will help you guard against falling back on your intuition during times of stress and indecision in negotiations.

Integrative Negotiation Strategy 1: Make a System 2 List.

The first step in negotiating more rationally is to identify real-life negotiation situations that call for extra vigilance.

Periodically, make a list of important upcoming negotiations that you think might require System 2 thought. Such negotiations might concern significant financial resources, complex issues, multiple parties, key strategic partners, or a new direction for your organization. When you carefully prepare for negotiations, you set yourself up to engage in System 2 thought in situations where it is required.

Integrative Negotiation Strategy 2: Don’t Let Time Pressure Affect Your Decisions

As noted, intuitive System 1 thought often takes over when negotiators are facing intense time pressure. Awareness of this tendency should lead you to make key adjustments to your negotiations.

For example, schedule your negotiations in advance so you don’t feel rushed to reach agreement. Tight deadlines foster intuitive shortcuts. And if someone catches you off guard and launches into discussions on the fly, ask to reschedule the conversation for a later date. Unless someone has given you specific, credible information that time truly is of the essence, avoid succumbing to pressure tactics to make decisions before you’ve had time to think them through.

Integrative Negotiation Strategy 3: Partition the Negotiation Across Multiple Sessions

Human beings have a natural desire for closure. As a result, most of us seek to reach an agreement or settlement as quickly as possible. But completing an entire negotiation in one session is typically unnecessary – and, in fact, sometimes impossible.

Even when you’re well prepared, a negotiation that is the slightest bit complex will raise new information, unforeseen issues, and tactics that you did not anticipate.

In negotiation, patience often generates significant dividends.

To avoid falling back on System 1 thinking, structure a process that allows you to rethink or re-strategize. You might schedule breaks every hour or two to give yourself time to evaluate and organize unexpected information. When you expect talks to be especially intricate, consider negotiating over multiple days. By giving yourself time to think things through, you’ll be in a better position to apply System 2 thought throughout the negotiation process.

Integrative Negotiation Strategy 4: Adopt an Outsider Lens

Why are we typically unaware of our own biases in negotiations, yet at the same time, capable of accurately pinpointing the biases that influence others?

Psychologists Daniel Kahneman of Princeton University and Daniel Lovallo of the Australian Graduate School of Management have argued that we make decisions using two different lenses: the insider lens and the outsider lens.

  • A negotiator typically uses an insider lens for making judgments when deeply immersed in a particular context or situation; the insider relies on intuitive System 1 thinking.
  • By contrast, the typical negotiator adopts an outsider lens when removed or detached from a particular situation; the outsider uses rational, System 2 thinking.

The insider focuses only on the current situation, while the outsider is better at integrating information across multiple episodes – in particular, other people’s successes and failures.

Obviously, for our most important negotiations, the outsider lens is preferable. Yet it’s rarely the default option when we are facing major negotiation or embroiled in conflict.

A negotiator might well be aware that it takes six to 12 weeks to move from an initial sales call to a legally binding agreement. Yet, when a new prospect comes along, she may nonetheless believe that she can close the deal within three weeks.

Furthermore, particularly for business negotiations, the overconfidence bias suggests that business negotiators are likely to continue to be overly confident about their odds of success despite being proven wrong in the past. In other words, most of us fail to learn from experience.

Integrative Negotiation Strategies and Tactics: Norms and How to Avoid Pitfalls 

Yet overconfidence remains the norm in negotiation. In a study by Arnold Cooper of Perdue University, Carolyn Woo of Notre Dame University, and Wiliam Dunkelberg of Temple University, more than 80% of entrepreneurs estimated their personal chances of success to be 70% or higher, and one-third described their success as certain.

In fact, the five-year survival rate for new businesses is only about 33%.

Many intelligent people stake their reputations, large sums of money, and years of their lives on intuition and overconfidence. (For more information on negotiator reputation, see Business Negotiations: How to Improve Your Reputation at the Bargaining Table.)

The strong urge to view the world – and ourselves – in a positive light can powerfully affect our decision making in negotiation.
How can you make sure the outsider view is represented at your most important negotiations?

  • Enlist an outsider. During preparation for a key negotiation, consider recruiting a true outsider, whether an expert within your firm, a consultant with unique experience, or a trusted friend. When your deal is complex or emotionally charged, others will identify factors that you have ignored and weight negative information more appropriately.
  • Take an outside view. If you are not willing or able to bring in an outsider, becoming an outsider yourself by assessing the situation as if you were not immersed in it. This strategy might require you to recall when someone else was faced with a similar situation or to collect data on what you should rationally expect. In addition, ask yourself this simple question: If someone I cared about asked me for my opinion in a negotiation such as this, what advice would I give?

The data is clear: the use of intuition creates the potential for significant psychological biases that lead to irrational decisions. The strategies above can help you identify when to incorporate careful, reasoned analysis into your negotiation judgments.

Are there any essential negotiation skills you think we’ve missed? Share them with us in the comments.

 

Related Posts

Comments

One Response to “Essential Negotiation Skills: Limiting Cognitive Bias in Negotiation”

  • Danielle R.

    Within the different functions of our brain, thinking more logically in negotiations will require the use of our neocortex and limiting our natural responses based on emotion that frequently takes place within the use of our Limbic System.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *