Obama as mediator?

By on / Daily, Mediation

Recently, a local incident grew into a national dispute that seemed ripe for mediation. After being locked out of his home and forcing his way in, Henry Louis Gates, an African-American Harvard University professor, had a confrontation with Cambridge, Massachusetts police sergeant James Crowley and was arrested for disorderly conduct. In a press conference, President Obama said the Cambridge police had acted “stupidly” in arresting Gates—and instantly, the minor news story was elevated into a national debate on race.

And so the “beer summit” was born. Obama welcomed Gates and Crowley to the White House and shared a round of beer with them and Vice President Joe Biden in the Rose Garden.

Given his stated opinion on the case and his political interest in the outcome, Obama was not in a position to play the role of impartial mediator. Yet the photo opportunity succeeded in bringing the disputants together. Gates and Crowley said they would be meeting again in private to discuss their moment in history in greater detail.

When two or more parties are having trouble negotiating their way through a dispute, mediation can bring them together. In “Make the Most of Mediation,” the lead article in the October issue of the Negotiation newsletter, we take an in-depth look at the benefits of mediation, show you how to choose a mediator, and explain how the process usually unfolds.

Related Posts

Comments

3 Responses to “Obama as mediator?”

  • But Obama did play the role of mediator in this situation. His acknowledged biases, being a friend of Gates, and having made a comment in Gates’s favor, did not preclude him acting as a mediator. Since a mediator, unlike a judge or arbitrator, does not decide the dispute for the parties, he does not need to be impartial in the same sense as a judge or arbitrator. He only needs to disclose his own biases.

    Not only in convening the beer summit, but in his whole approach to governance, Obama displays classic mediator techniques, as I and others have noted.

    http://www.mediate-la.com/2009/05/president-sounds-like-mediator.html

    Reply
  • But Obama did play the role of mediator in this situation. His acknowledged biases, being a friend of Gates, and having made a comment in Gates’s favor, did not preclude him acting as a mediator. Since a mediator, unlike a judge or arbitrator, does not decide the dispute for the parties, he does not need to be impartial in the same sense as a judge or arbitrator. He only needs to disclose his own biases.

    Not only in convening the beer summit, but in his whole approach to governance, Obama displays classic mediator techniques, as I and others have noted.

    http://www.mediate-la.com/2009/05/president-sounds-like-mediator.html

    Reply
  • Syed Qamar Afzal R.

    By all accounts, negotiation or mediation skills seem to have been the required deserts of the best diplomats;yet to comment on President Obama’s ability regarding a mediator, I would like to say that Obama’s astuteness in this regard largely depends on how far he becomes instrumental in dealing/tackling with the Taliban issue.

    Reply

Leave a Reply