Explore Our Free Negotiation Reports

settling out of court

Settling Out of Court: Negotiating in the Shadow of the Law

By following best practices for settling out of court, you can keep your dispute private—and turn it into a value-creating deal.

When a serious business dispute arise, we sometimes must confront the difficult decision of whether to work toward a settlement on our own, engage in mediation, or hand the outcome over to a judge, jury, or arbitrator.

Parties often stand to gain by resolving their disagreements before they reach the courtroom, write Robert H. Mnookin, Scott R. Peppet, and Andrew S. Tulumello explain in Beyond Winning: Negotiating to Create Value in Deals and Disputes. Yet disputants and their lawyers frequently underestimate the financial, emotional, and strategic costs of pursuing a legal battle.

Here, we explore why those costs are so often overlooked, how you can improve your chances of settling out of court, and the circumstances in which litigation may, in fact, be the wiser path.

Settling out of Court vs. Litigating

Settling out of court can eliminate any number of barriers to negotiation. The drawbacks of involving lawyers in your dispute and preparing for a lawsuit can be considerable.

1. Transaction Costs

Parties can incur significant transaction costs from a looming lawsuit, including legal fees and the loss of their precious time. In fact, one or both sides to a dispute may try to persuade the other party to make concessions by deliberately attempting to increase the other party’s transaction costs—for instance, by requesting mountains of documents and presenting long lists of questions that take many billable hours to answer.

Your own legal team may also have financial incentives to drag out a discovery process to pad its fees—to your disadvantage. And when estimating likely legal fees, disputants often fail to factor in the time and expense of further litigation if they end up in court and the “loser” decides to appeal the court’s decision.

2. Lack of Cooperation

The widespread misconception that the best lawyers are aggressive and rigid, and never collaborative or accommodating can lead clients to hold back their legal team from exploring creative (and money-saving) tradeoffs. For lawyers, a client’s expectations of toughness can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. It’s not uncommon for both sides in a dispute to begin puffing up their positions and claims and to give the impression that they won’t back down under any circumstances.

In this environment, parties unfortunately tend to perceive concessions and compromise as signs of weakness and vulnerability rather than as potential value-creating moves, write the authors of Beyond Winning.

3. Damaged Relationships

Negotiators often fail to thoroughly consider the effects of legal action on their relationships with the other side and with other interested parties. “Disputes may strain relationships, but litigation tends to destroy them,” according to Harvard Business School professor Deepak Malhotra.

To take an obvious example, a divorcing couple that is able to negotiate a child-custody arrangement with the help of a neutral mediator may be more likely to build a productive post-divorce relationship, to the benefit of themselves and their children, than a couple that hires two “sharks” to attack each other’s character in court.

These drawbacks of litigation aside, it can sometimes be the best means of helping you meet a particular set of goals.

When litigation is the best option

Though negotiation (whether conducted through lawyers, mediators, or on your own) should lead to better outcomes for disputants in most cases, litigation may be preferable in the following situations, writes Jeffrey R. Seul in a chapter in The Handbook of Dispute Resolution:

  • An uncooperative counterpart. If your adversary stalls or refuses to negotiate in good faith, you might turn the case over to courts to ensure that it will eventually be resolved (though not necessarily in your favor). Court-ordered discovery will also legally compel a recalcitrant counterpart to supply information he might have held back during a dispute-resolution process.
  • A desire for openness and publicity. If you want to draw attention to your counterpart’s behavior or clear your name, you might choose to pursue a litigation process in which the outcome may be publicized, instead of private negotiations.
  • Deterring false charges. If you have been the repeated victim of false claims and opportunism, taking such cases to court may (if you win) deter others from targeting you in the future.
  • Settling legal questions. If deciding a dispute according to established legal norms or potentially setting new precedents is important to you, you might prefer to give decision-making authority to the courts.

Settling out of Court

The following guidelines can help you settle out of court and reach creative, mutually beneficial resolutions to your disputes, with or without lawyers at the table.

1. Make sure the process is perceived as fair.

Before tackling your dispute jointly, negotiate key elements of the process with your counterpart, such as how you will choose experts and whether lawyers will be involved in negotiations. Doing so will increase the odds that both sides will view the final outcome as unbiased and fair. In addition, you might suggest that you jointly hire a professional mediator to lead the settlement process instead of turning the process over to your lawyers.

2. Identify interests and tradeoffs.

Even when we’re determined to settle out of court, the win-lose format of a looming litigation can encourage us to view negotiation as a battle. Unfortunately, the desire to prove we’re right can distract us from pursuing our underlying interests. It can also propel us all the way up the courthouse steps if our adversary refuses to meet our needs.

Just as in business dealmaking, you can expand the pie of value in a dispute by opening up about your key interests and preferences, which can help you identify potential tradeoffs. Revisit the following questions often during the dispute-resolution process:

  • What are my true underlying interests?
  • How can I best achieve them?
  • How much am I willing to pay just to be able to say that I won?

It’s also important to encourage the other party to open up about her interests and to keep those interests in mind as you negotiate.

3. Insist on decision analysis.

Lawyers are often hesitant to quantify their clients’ odds of winning court cases, write Mnookin, Peppet, and Tulumello in Beyond Winning. Yet you need a thorough analysis of the risks and opportunities of litigation to make informed predictions and decisions about how to move forward. Any lawyers you hire should be well versed in decision-analysis tools such as decision trees and dependency diagrams and ready to use them to help improve the quality of your decisions.

4. Reduce discovery costs.

Disputants who are considering a lawsuit often become trapped in a lengthy and time-consuming discovery process that includes searching through reams of data and conducting depositions. You should be able to reduce these expenses by negotiating a low-cost exchange of essential information with your counterpart, write the Beyond Winning authors. When you can keep costs down, both sides win.

Continue the Discussion

Do you have experience settling out of course? Leave a comment below.

negotiauction

In Negotiauctions, Try a Game-Changing Move

Negotiauctions combine the competitive bidding of auctions with the one-on-one dealmaking of negotiations. The TV show Shark Tank offers lessons on best practices for such complex negotiation-auction hybrids.

Often in business negotiations, we must compete not only with a counterpart across the table but also with others fighting for the same deal. A procurement officer may announce to a longtime supplier that she is putting their contract up for an auction. Or bidders for a company might be invited to negotiate elements of the deal. Harvard Law School and Harvard Business School professor Guhan Subramanian calls such situations negotiauctions because they combine the competitive bidding of an auction with the one-on-one dealmaking of a negotiation.

Businesspeople often are uncertain about how to get a foothold in negotiauctions. To see how experienced negotiators manage competition on both sides of the table, they might want to watch the reality-TV show Shark Tank. The show’s format roughly mimics the process that entrepreneurs go through when seeking venture capital (VC) funding, with a focus on consumer products. Shark Tank is bringing creative negotiauctions to the attention of a wide audience.

Negotiating with Sharks

In Shark Tank, real-life entrepreneurs take turns entering the “shark tank” (a TV studio) to stand before five actual VC investors, the “sharks.” Each entrepreneur or team pitches a money-making product or service and makes an opening offer: a request for a specific amount of funding in exchange for equity in the company (for example, $50,000 for a 10% stake). The sharks then ask probing questions aimed at assessing the product’s sales potential and the entrepreneur’s business acumen and drive.

Next, the sharks reveal one at a time whether they will accept the entrepreneur’s offer as is, try to negotiate a better deal, or go “out” (pass on the deal). The entrepreneurs can accept only one deal, which is sealed with a handshake and negotiated further offstage. Final deals typically include both financing and mentorship. Because the sharks can bid against one another but also negotiate one-on-one with the entrepreneur, the format is a negotiauction.

Consider a segment from a May 2014 episode. College student Kaeya Majmundar presented the sharks with her prototype for a collapsible storage box, BZbox. After demonstrating that BZbox was a snap to assemble, Majmundar asked for $50,000 in exchange for 20% of her business, contingent on her ability to have the product manufactured.

Three sharks quickly dropped out, saying the price per box ($1.75) needed to be significantly lower to be competitive with conventional cardboard boxes. Just two sharks remained: Canadian businessman Kevin O’Leary and Lori Greiner, the “Queen of QVC” (the home-shopping network).

O’Leary opened by offering Majmundar $50,000 for 50% equity if she could reduce the price per box to 56 cents.

“Is that the only offer that I’m going to get?” Majmundar asked.

Greiner, the final potential bidder, described her qualms with the product. “Come on, Lori,” Majmundar said. “I know that you’re the partner that I need.”

“I’m out,” O’Leary interrupted. “You never say that when you’re negotiating after you’ve got an offer, because you don’t know what the outcome is. You made a huge mistake!”

Majmundar nodded gravely, then turned back to Greiner. “Please, Lori, just listen to me. . . . I will do anything it takes.”

Greiner ended up offering $50,000 for 40% of Majmundar’s business, contingent on how well the manufacturing process turned out. 

“Lori, you have a deal,” Majmundar said with visible relief.

Lessons for Negotiauctions

In an interview with the Chicago Tribune, Majmundar revealed that Greiner’s offer fell through after the show but that the businesswoman had been serving as her mentor. The young entrepreneur sold a flurry of boxes after the episode aired but turned to launching a different product.

During her Shark Tank appearance, Majmundar faced the unenviable task of trying to keep two negotiations spinning without letting either one crash—a common challenge for “auctioneers” in negotiauctions. As O’Leary noted, letting a potential partner find out you’d rather build a relationship with his competitor before you have a solid offer is not a smart negotiating move. 

As the process setter in negotiauctions, you may be able to reduce this risk by minimizing delays between discussions with competitors. Once you have two or more solid offers, you can try to play bidders against one another on issues where they can compete, such as price. 

3 Game-Changing Strategies for Bidders in Negotiauctions

In negotiauctions, bidders can gain an edge over the competition through “the relentless pursuit of game-changing moves,” writes Subramanian in his book Dealmaking: The New Strategy of Negotiauctions:

  1. Setup moves that establish terms of entry.

In a traditional auction, a seller (or sometimes a buyer) sets the rules, and bidders follow them. But when your entry into a competitive situation has value, don’t give it away. When O’Leary made his offer to Majmundar, for example, his entry had enormous value because she had no other offers on the table. O’Leary extracted a concession in exchange for his bid: Get the cost of the product down to 56 cents. In other instances, wise negotiators extract process concessions, such as an exclusivity period or a commitment from the auctioneer for a single “best-and-final offer” round.

  1. Rearrange moves that increases the value of the deal.

If you find yourself in a weak position, a rearranging move can help unlock value. For example, two bidders in an auction might decide to pool their resources and submit a joint bid. Rearranging moves happen occasionally in the mergers-and-acquisitions world, where buyers can gain leverage when bidding on a prized company by joining forces. 

  1. Shutdown moves that prematurely cut off the competition.

Shutdown moves that end the auction prematurely are a common tool among the VCs of Shark Tank. For example, Cuban will sometimes make an offer before the other sharks have heard enough about an entrepreneur’s product to know whether they want to bid—but he will condition his offer on the entrepreneur’s immediate acceptance. Cuban is trying to short-circuit a competitive process with the other sharks through a shutdown move. The shutdown move often works because the entrepreneur wants to partner with Cuban, and the threat of his “short fuse” is highly credible.

What advice do you have for those participating in negotiauctions?

business negotiators

On Social Media, Business Negotiators Should Post with Caution

In this example of business negotiators getting their way, actor Harry Shearer used Twitter to gain leverage in his contract renegotiation for The Simpsons—but that doesn’t mean you should follow his lead.

When it comes to getting what they want, some business negotiators take it to the social media streets.

Back in May of 2015, actor Harry Shearer, the voice of iconic characters on the hit animated TV series The Simpsons since its inception in 1989, announced via Twitter that he was leaving the show because of an impasse with Fox Television over the terms of his contract for the show’s 27th and 28th seasons. Shearer, the voice of Mr. Burns, Ned Flanders, Principal Skinner, and dozens of other Simpsons characters, tweeted a quote that he said came from the lawyer of co-executive producer James L. Brooks: “[The] show will go on, Harry will not be part of it, wish him the best.” Shearer clarified, “This [is] because I wanted what we’ve always had: the freedom to do other work.”

As Simpsons fans weighed in on the news with dismayed tweets, Brooks and the show’s other executive producers, Matt Groening and Al Jean, released a statement saying that Fox had offered Shearer “the same deal” as the show’s other main cast members, all five of whom had accepted. That deal was reportedly $300,000 each per episode, or about $13.2 million for the two seasons, plus an option for two more seasons. “The show will go on, and we wish him well,” the producers said about Shearer. “Maggie [the fictional Simpsons’ baby] took it hard.”

But that wasn’t the end of the line for the business negotiators in this story. Ultimately, the saga illustrates both the pros and cons of taking disputes public in negotiation, particularly in the heated forum of social media.

To be continued . . .

Responding to Shearer’s tweets in an interview with Entertainment Weekly, show producer Jean left the door open for the actor’s return, saying, “We’re still hoping he might come back.” Shearer, after all, had been the cast’s lone holdout during 2011 cast renegotiations, only to sign in the end.

Jean went on to characterize Shearer’s tweets as “very surprising” and inaccurate, given that the actor had an offer on the table to which he had not yet responded. “He said it wasn’t about the money, and I don’t think it is either,” Jean continued. Nor did the producer understand Shearer’s complaint about lacking freedom to do other work. Shearer, he said, had been given special permission in the past to do script readings and voice recordings for The Simpsons over the phone so that he could pursue his other interests. (Shearer has juggled his work on The Simpsons with a weekly radio show, sketch comedy, and BBC radio documentaries, among other projects.)

For fairness reasons, Jean said, the producers would not bump up Shearer’s offer above what the show’s five other main stars had already accepted. Reiterating that the show would go on without Shearer, if necessary, Jean discussed detailed plans to hire a roster of actors to fill his many roles. “We’ve had three really good [table] reads without Harry,” Jean said, speaking of the new season. “It’s not like we’re sitting there going, ‘Oh, this is a disaster.’”

For his part, producer Brooks sent an olive branch over Twitter: “Hey, we tried. We’re still trying. Harry, no kidding, let’s talk.”

An excellent ending

“Discussions are happening at a level where decisions can be made,” Shearer reassured a Simpsons fan somewhat cryptically on Twitter in late May. A month later, speaking on a panel with Brooks at a television festival, producer Jean revealed that talks with Shearer remained “in limbo.” “I think it will be tied in with the Iran deal that the U.S. is negotiating,” he quipped. “It’ll be one big package.”

On July 7, Entertainment Weekly broke the news that Shearer and The Simpsons’ producers had reached agreement on a new two-year contract. He reportedly was signing the same contract as the show’s other five primary voice actors.

“All I can say is, it wasn’t a stunt,” Shearer told the Guardian. “There were real issues that had to be resolved, and they were.” He later credited the support and encouragement he received from Simpsons fans for bringing him back to the negotiating table. Without them, he told the New Orleans Times-Picayune, “I don’t think this day would’ve turned out so happily. That’s the truth.”

Other details of the agreement remained under wraps, but a couple of revelations in the media hint at why Shearer held out for so long.

First, Shearer had admitted in the past to having conflicting emotions about his earnings. “As an actor on an insanely successful TV series, I am by any standard of the human species obscenely overpaid,” Shearer said on comedian Marc Maron’s WTF podcast. “It is also true that as an actor on one of the most insanely successful TV series of all time, I am also getting royally [taken advantage of]. Both things are true!”

During a Bloomberg Masters in Business podcast, Shearer elaborated that “those who got in early” on The Simpsons’ success, other than the actors, “are getting the lion’s share. I have to be happy with what we [the actors] got.” Business negotiators often care just as much about getting a fair deal as they do about their objective outcomes, research has found. That may have been the case for Shearer.

Second, a series of tweets from Jean on the day Shearer’s new contract was announced suggest the recent standoff was precipitated by a perceived slight. “I have recently been told that during a period when Harry Shearer believed he had a five-week free period from The Simpsons, I was unaware of this fact, and did in fact request material from him,” Jean wrote. “I am truly glad he is returning to the show.” Shearer’s initial tweet about not having the freedom to do other work may have reflected residual anger at being asked to do work for The Simpsons during a hiatus.

Toward more “okally-dokally” deals for business negotiators

The drawn-out, public nature of Shearer’s negotiation suggests the following advice to anyone who feels tempted to take their dispute to the court of public opinion:

1. Exhaust private negotiations first.

Shearer’s reluctance to sign may have been rooted in an unintentional violation of his creative freedom by Jean as well as long-standing resentment about what the actor perceived to be an unfair distribution of the show’s ample profits. Rather than trying to sort out these issues in private, Shearer appears to have taken his grievances directly to the public. His announcement that he was leaving put his counterparts on the defensive. The parties were able to reach an amicable agreement, but only after returning to private negotiations.

In negotiation, the larger our audience is, the more aggressively we are likely to behave. When we take our disputes public, we feel compelled to “save face” by maintaining our tough stance. In the process, we squander our ability to brainstorm creative concessions and proposals. The next time you feel like venting your frustrations with a counterpart on social media (or traditional media, for that matter), air them privately instead. Even if you feel ready to walk away, at least give the other side the opportunity to listen to and try to address your concerns.

If you feel you have little choice but to air your grievances, be sure you can make a compelling case and run your plans (and posts) by trusted, unbiased advisers. Then try to get back to private negotiations as quickly as possible.

2. Be sure to address all their interests.

Jean’s confused response to Shearer’s initial tweets suggests he and the other producers lacked a clear sense of the actor’s interests in the renegotiation, beyond salary. Shearer let it be known that he had a strong interest in protecting his time away from The Simpsons to work on other projects, and he also appears to have believed that the producers had not respected this key interest in the past. As a business negotiator, ask probing questions aimed at uncovering all of your counterpart’s interests before making an initial offer—and then ensure your first offer meets as many of those interests as possible.

3. Use benchmarks to set an anchor for what’s fair.

The Simpsons producers’ decision to offer the same compensation to all six of the show’s lead actors paid off in their negotiation with Shearer. The salary benchmark of $300,000 per episode became a credible anchor on which they could base their refusal to offer him more money. Because most business negotiators understand such appeals to fairness, monetary benchmarks can be an effective means of holding firm on price.

In business contracts, “most favored nation” (or “most favored customer”) clauses can serve a similar function. With such clauses, a seller promises to give a buyer the same best terms it gives its other buyers. A supplier, for example, might promise a retailer that its competitors will have to pay the very same price for the supplier’s products. Buyers appreciate the fairness of such clauses, which can also work to the advantage of sellers. If a buyer asks for a lower price, the seller can respond, “I could, but then I’d have to give the same lower price to everyone.” The buyer is likely to understand, see less advantage from a lower price, and back down.

What else did you take away from this negotiation? Do you have advice for these business negotiators? Leave a comment below and let’s discuss.

managing expectations

Dear Negotiation Coach: Managing Expectations With Work Assignments

Managing expectations in the workplace can sometimes be as simple as reframing a topic as a mutual negotiation.

Managers often find themselves managing expectations in the workplace. Sometimes, however, managing expectations isn’t just about employees and staff, it can be about our own ideas of how the workplace functions. Such was the case with a question we received regarding the delegation of a new project.

Here’s the original question:

I recently asked one of our firm’s managers, Joseph, to be in charge of developing an important new program. He agreed to take it on and didn’t raise any concerns, but I sensed a lack of enthusiasm during our conversation. This surprised me, as I had assumed that he would feel honored and happily run with the new role. Now I’m worried he won’t do a good job, and I think maybe I should have chosen someone else. What should I do?

Managing expectation through negotiation and getting things done

Before concluding that you chose the wrong person to head up your new initiative, take a few minutes to review what happened. You might have benefited from viewing your conversation with Joseph as a negotiation, as he didn’t seem to have a voice in deciding whether he should be involved and how. Managers often make the mistake of relying on their authority to impose their will, when a back-and-forth negotiation, though more time-consuming, would be more likely to lead to positive outcomes.

An important part of any negotiation is trying to see how the situation looks to the other party. Before asking Joseph to take on this new project, did you imagine how he would view the request? Because you are Joseph’s supervisor, there is a power imbalance between you, and it would not be unusual for someone in his situation to hide his interests.

It’s possible that one or more of these thoughts ran through his head:

  • I want to take on this new project, but how am I going to get my usual work done as well?
  • If the project goes well, I won’t get the credit. If it doesn’t, I’ll be blamed.
  • I’m too busy to do this, but it’s hopeless to complain. The decision is made.
  • I don’t know if I’m up to the task. It’s a much more complicated project than I’m used to handling.

Once you realize that Joseph may view your request differently than you do, you will be prepared to have a follow-up conversation in which you test your assumptions—that he would welcome the opportunity, be able to handle the extra workload, and feel prepared to carry it out. When you invite him in for a second meeting, you might say, “I know I may have surprised you by asking you to take on this new project, and I want to check in with you. How do you feel about it, and how do you think it could fit in with your current responsibilities?” Ask open-ended questions that will encourage him to elaborate on his initial thoughts.

If you frame the second conversation as a shared problem—there is new work to be done, and together you need to figure out how to do it—you can foster an open, collegial discussion. When you brainstorm ways to solve the problem, you may come up with an even better solution than having Joseph take the project on alone. For example, you might recruit support staff to help him or divide up the project’s main roles among others at his level.

At the same time, you need to remain aware of the fact that you are Joseph’s manager. You can work toward managing expectations, but you still have the right to assign work, and you don’t want people to be able to veto or sabotage your decisions. The work needs to get done.

In negotiation, it is important to balance empathy and assertiveness, a tension first described in the negotiation classic Beyond Winning: Negotiating to Create Value in Deals and Disputes (Harvard University Press, 2000) by Robert H. Mnookin, Scott R. Peppet, and Andrew S. Tulumello. Although, understandably, your first instinct as a manager is to assert your own interests, it is also important to show empathy—not just to be kind but to potentially uncover new information that will help you reach a better agreement.

Above all, you want to end up with a sustainable agreement in which the project gets done well and the person leading it is fully engaged. Is Joseph the right person for the job? With good negotiation analysis and thoughtful questioning, you will be able to answer that question.

What advice would you share for managing expectations – both your own and that of your subordinates?

 

Dear Negotiation Coach: Negotiating work assignments with subordinates

QUESTION

I recently asked one of our firm’s managers, Joseph, to be in charge of developing an important new program. He agreed to take it on and didn’t raise any concerns, but I sensed a lack of enthusiasm during our conversation. This surprised me, as I had assumed that he would feel honored and happily run with the new role. Now I’m worried he won’t do a good job, and I think maybe I should have chosen someone else. What should I do?

ANSWER

Before concluding that you chose the wrong person to head up your new initiative, take a few minutes to review what happened. You might have benefited from viewing your conversation with Joseph as a negotiation, as he didn’t seem to have a voice in deciding whether he should be involved and how. Managers often make the mistake of relying on their authority to impose their will, when a back-and-forth negotiation, though more time-consuming, would be more likely to lead to positive outcomes.

An important part of any negotiation is trying to see how the situation looks to the other party. Before asking Joseph to take on this new project, did you imagine how he would view the request? Because you are Joseph’s supervisor, there is a power imbalance between you, and it would not be unusual for someone in his situation to hide his interests.

It’s possible that one or more of these thoughts ran through his head:

• I want to take on this new project, but how am I going to get my usual work done as well?

• If the project goes well, I won’t get the credit. If it doesn’t, I’ll be blamed.

• I’m too busy to do this, but it’s hopeless to complain. The decision is made.

• I don’t know if I’m up to the task. It’s a much more complicated project than I’m used to handling.

Once you realize that Joseph may view your request differently than you do, you will be prepared to have a follow-up conversation in which you test your assumptions—that he would welcome the opportunity, be able to handle the extra workload, and feel prepared to carry it out. When you invite him in for a second meeting, you might say, “I know I may have surprised you by asking you to take on this new project, and I want to check in with you. How do you feel about it, and how do you think it could fit in with your current responsibilities?” Ask open-ended questions that will encourage him to elaborate on his initial thoughts.

If you frame the second conversation as a shared problem—there is new work to be done, and together you need to figure out how to do it—you can foster an open, collegial discussion. When you brainstorm ways to solve the problem, you may come up with an even better solution than having Joseph take the project on alone. For example, you might recruit support staff to help him or divide up the project’s main roles among others at his level.

At the same time, you need to remain aware of the fact that you are Joseph’s manager. You have the right to assign work, and you don’t want people to be able to veto or sabotage your decisions. The work needs to get done.

In negotiation, it is important to balance empathy and assertiveness, a tension first described in the negotiation classic Beyond Winning: Negotiating to Create Value in Deals and Disputes (Harvard University Press, 2000) by Robert H. Mnookin, Scott R. Peppet, and Andrew S. Tulumello. Although, understandably, your first instinct as a manager is to assert your own interests, it is also important to show empathy—not just to be kind but to potentially uncover new information that will help you reach a better agreement.

Above all, you want to end up with a sustainable agreement in which the project gets done well and the person leading it is fully engaged. Is Joseph the right person for the job? With good negotiation analysis and thoughtful questioning, you will be able to answer that question.

Susan Hackley
Managing Director
Program on Negotiation
Harvard Law School

On Social Media, Business Negotiators Should Post with Caution

On Social Media, Business Negotiators Should Post with Caution

Actor Harry Shearer used Twitter to gain leverage in his contract renegotiation for The Simpsons—but that doesn’t mean you should follow his lead.

On May 13, actor Harry Shearer, the voice of iconic characters on the hit animated TV series The Simpsons since its inception in 1989, announced via Twitter that he was leaving the show because of an impasse with Fox Television over the terms of his contract for the show’s 27th and 28th seasons. Shearer, the voice of Mr. Burns, Ned Flanders, Principal Skinner, and dozens of other Simpsons characters, tweeted a quote that he said came from the lawyer of coexecutive producer James L. Brooks: “[The] show will go on, Harry will not be part of it, wish him the best.” Shearer clarified, “This [is] because I wanted what we’ve always had: the freedom to do other work.”

As Simpsons fans weighed in on the news with dismayed tweets, Brooks and the show’s other executive producers, Matt Groening and Al Jean, released a statement saying that Fox had offered Shearer “the same deal” as the show’s other main cast members, all five of whom had accepted. That deal was reportedly $300,000 each per episode, or about $13.2 million for the two seasons, plus an option for two more seasons. “The show will go on, and we wish him well,” the producers said about Shearer. “Maggie [the fictional Simpsons’ baby] took it hard.”

But that wasn’t the end of the story. Ultimately, the saga illustrates both the pros and cons of taking disputes public in negotiation, particularly in the heated forum of social media.

To be continued . . .

Responding to Shearer’s tweets in an interview with Entertainment Weekly, show producer Jean left the door open for the actor’s return, saying, “We’re still hoping he might come back.” Shearer, after all, had been the cast’s lone holdout during 2011 cast renegotiations, only to sign in the end.

Jean went on to characterize Shearer’s tweets as “very surprising” and inaccurate, given that the actor had an offer on the table to which he had not yet responded. “He said it wasn’t about the money, and I don’t think it is either,” Jean continued. Nor did the producer understand Shearer’s complaint about lacking freedom to do other work. Shearer, he said, had been given special permission in the past to do script readings and voice recordings for The Simpsons over the phone so that he could pursue his other interests. (Shearer has juggled his work on The Simpsons with a weekly radio show, sketch comedy, and BBC radio documentaries, among other projects.)

For fairness reasons, Jean said, the producers would not bump up Shearer’s offer above what the show’s five other main stars had already accepted. Reiterating that the show would go on without Shearer, if necessary, Jean discussed detailed plans to hire a roster of actors to fill his many roles. “We’ve had three really good [table] reads without Harry,” Jean said, speaking of the new season. “It’s not like we’re sitting there going, ‘Oh, this is a disaster.’”

For his part, producer Brooks sent an olive branch over Twitter: “Hey, we tried. We’re still trying. Harry, no kidding, let’s talk.”

An excellent ending

“Discussions are happening at a level where decisions can be made,” Shearer reassured a Simpsons fan somewhat cryptically on Twitter in late May. A month later, speaking on a panel with Brooks at a television festival, producer Jean revealed that talks with Shearer remained “in limbo.” “I think it will be tied in with the Iran deal that the U.S. is negotiating,” he quipped. “It’ll be one big package.”

On July 7, Entertainment Weekly broke the news that Shearer and The Simpsons’ producers had reached agreement on a new two-year contract. He reportedly was signing the same contract as the show’s other five primary voice actors.

“All I can say is, it wasn’t a stunt,” Shearer told the Guardian. “There were real issues that had to be resolved, and they were.” He later credited the support and encouragement he received from Simpsons fans for bringing him back to the negotiating table. Without them, he told the New Orleans Times-Picayune, “I don’t think this day would’ve turned out so happily. That’s the truth.”

Other details of the agreement remained under wraps, but a couple of revelations in the media hint at why Shearer held out for so long. First, Shearer had admitted in the past to having conflicting emotions about his earnings. “As an actor on an insanely successful TV series, I am by any standard of the human species obscenely overpaid,” Shearer said in February on comedian Marc Maron’s WTF podcast. “It is also true that as an actor on one of the most insanely successful TV series of all time, I am also getting royally [taken advantage of]. Both things are true!” During a September Bloomberg Masters in Business podcast, Shearer elaborated that “those who got in early” on The Simpsons’ success, other than the actors, “are getting the lion’s share. I have to be happy with what we [the actors] got.” Negotiators often care just as much about getting a fair deal as they do about their objective outcomes, research has found. That may have been the case for Shearer.

Second, a series of tweets from Jean on the day Shearer’s new contract was announced suggest the recent standoff was precipitated by a perceived slight. “I have recently been told that during a period when Harry Shearer believed he had a five-week free period from The Simpsons, I was unaware of this fact, and did in fact request material from him,” Jean wrote. “I am truly glad he is returning to the show.” Shearer’s initial tweet about not having the freedom to do other work may have reflected residual anger at being asked to do work for The Simpsons during a hiatus.

Toward more “okally-dokally” negotiations

The drawn-out, public nature of Shearer’s negotiation suggests the following advice to anyone who feels tempted to take their dispute to the court of public opinion:

1. Exhaust private negotiations first.

Shearer’s reluctance to sign may have been rooted in an unintentional violation of his creative freedom by Jean as well as long-standing resentment about what the actor perceived to be an unfair distribution of the show’s ample profits. Rather than trying to sort out these issues in private, Shearer appears to have taken his grievances directly to the public. His announcement that he was leaving put his counterparts on the defensive. The parties were able to reach an amicable agreement, but only after returning to private negotiations.

In negotiation, the larger our audience is, the more aggressively we are likely to behave. When we take our disputes public, we feel compelled to “save face” by maintaining our tough stance. In the process, we squander our ability to brainstorm creative concessions and proposals. The next time you feel like venting your frustrations with a counterpart on social media (or traditional media, for that matter), air them privately instead. Even if you feel ready to walk away, at least give the other side the opportunity to listen to and try to address your concerns.
If you feel you have little choice but to air your grievances, be sure you can make a compelling case and run your plans (and posts) by trusted, unbiased advisers. Then try to get back to private negotiations as quickly as possible.

2. Be sure to address all their interests.

Jean’s confused response to Shearer’s initial tweets suggests he and the other producers lacked a clear sense of the actor’s interests in the renegotiation, beyond salary. Shearer let it be known that he had a strong interest in protecting his time away from The Simpsons to work on other projects, and he also appears to have believed that the producers had not respected this key interest in the past. In negotiation, ask probing questions aimed at uncovering all of your counterpart’s interests before making an initial offer—and then ensure your first offer meets as many of those interests as possible.

3. Use benchmarks to set an anchor for what’s fair.

The Simpsons producers’ decision to offer the same compensation to all six of the show’s lead actors paid off in their negotiation with Shearer. The salary benchmark of $300,000 per episode became a credible anchor on which they could base their refusal to offer him more money. Because most negotiators understand such appeals to fairness, monetary benchmarks can be an effective means of holding firm on price.

In business contracts, “most favored nation” (or “most favored customer”) clauses can serve a similar function. With such clauses, a seller promises to give a buyer the same best terms it gives its other buyers. A supplier, for example, might promise a retailer that its competitors will have to pay the very same price for the supplier’s products. Buyers appreciate the fairness of such clauses, which can also work to the advantage of sellers. If a buyer asks for a lower price, the seller can respond, “I could, but then I’d have to give the same lower price to everyone.” The buyer is likely to understand, see less advantage from a lower price, and back down.

Try a Game-Changing Move in Your Next “Negotiauction”

When competing against multiple bidders, learn how to swim with the sharks.

Increasingly in the business world, negotiators must compete not only with their counterpart across the table but also with others fighting for the same deal. A procurement officer may announce to a longtime supplier that she is putting their contract up for an auction for the first time, for example. Or competitors bidding for a coveted company might be invited to negotiate elements of the deal. Harvard Law School and Harvard Business School professor Guhan Subramanian calls such situations negotiauctions because they combine the competitive bidding of an auction with the one-on-one dealmaking of a negotiation.

Businesspeople often are uncertain about how to get a foothold in the unfamiliar and sometimes rocky terrain of a negotiauction. To see how experienced negotiators manage competition on both sides of the table, they might want to check out an episode or two of the American reality-TV show Shark Tank. The show’s format roughly mimics the process that entrepreneurs go through when seeking venture capital (VC) funding in California’s Silicon Valley or on Greater Boston’s Route 128, though the focus of the show is almost entirely consumer-oriented products. For many people fascinated by negotiation and entrepreneurship, Shark Tank is a guilty pleasure—but it is also bringing creative negotiauction moves to the attention of a wide audience.

Negotiating with sharks

Here’s how Shark Tank works. In each episode, real-life entrepreneurs take turns entering the “shark tank” (a TV studio) to stand before five actual VC investors, the “sharks,” seated next to one another in a row. Each entrepreneur or entrepreneurial team then pitches a money-making product or service and makes an opening offer: a request for a specific amount of funding in exchange for equity in the company (for example, $50,000 for a 10% stake). After hearing the pitch, the sharks ask probing questions aimed at assessing the product’s sales potential and the entrepreneur’s business acumen and drive.

Next, the sharks reveal one at a time to the entrepreneur whether they will accept his or her offer as is, try to negotiate a better deal, or go “out” (pass on the deal). The entrepreneurs can accept only one deal, which is sealed with a handshake and negotiated further offstage. Final deals typically include both financing and mentorship from the winning shark. Because the sharks—including businessman and Dallas Mavericks owner Mark Cuban and inventor Lori Greiner, the “queen of QVC” (the home-shopping network)—can bid against one another but also negotiate one-on-one with the entrepreneur (all in the space of about 10 minutes), the format is that of a negotiauction.

To see how the sharks variously compete with one another and with the entrepreneur, consider a segment from a May 2014 episode of the show. Emory University student Kaeya Majmundar presented the sharks with her prototype for a collapsible storage box she’d dubbed BZbox. After demonstrating that her box was a snap to assemble, Majmundar made an opening request for $50,000 in exchange for 20% of her business, contingent on her ability to have the product manufactured.

The sharks were underwhelmed. Three of them quickly dropped out, expressing concern that the price per box ($1.75) needed to be significantly lower to be competitive with conventional cardboard storage boxes. Just two sharks remained: Canadian businessman Kevin O’Leary and Greiner.

O’Leary opened by offering Majmundar $50,000 for 50% equity if she could find a way to reduce the price per box to 56 cents.

“Is that the only offer that I’m going to get?” Majmundar asked, looking worried.

Greiner, the final potential bidder, began to describe her qualms with the product. “Come on, Lori,” Majmundar said. Soon she was begging her for an offer. “I know that you’re the partner that I need.”

“I’m out,” O’Leary interrupted. “You never say that when you’re negotiating after you’ve got an offer,” he continued, referring to Majmundar’s insinuation that she preferred Greiner over himself. “Because you don’t know what the outcome is. You made a huge mistake!”

Majmundar nodded gravely, then turned her attention back to Greiner. “Please, Lori, just listen to me. I will work for you. I will listen to you. I will do anything it takes.”

Greiner ended up offering $50,000 for 40% of Majmundar’s box business, contingent on how well the manufacturing process turned out. “It’s really going to be something to figure out, but I’m willing to take the journey with you,” Greiner said.

“Lori, you have a deal,” Majmundar said with visible relief.

Lessons for “negotiauctioneers”

In a follow-up interview with the Chicago Tribune, Majmundar revealed that Greiner’s offer ended up falling through after the show but that the businesswoman had been serving as her mentor. The young entrepreneur sold a flurry of her boxes after the episode aired but eventually turned her attention to launching a different product.
During her Shark Tank appearance, Majmundar faced the unenviable task of trying to keep two negotiations spinning without letting either one crash to the ground—a common challenge for the “auctioneer” in a negotiauction. As O’Leary noted, letting a potential partner find out you’d rather build a relationship with his competitor, particularly before that competitor has made a solid offer, clearly is not a smart negotiating move. Putting a good offer from Bidder 1 on hold to negotiate with Bidder 2 could convey to Bidder 1 that you’re not 100% interested in working with him and lead him to drop out of the race, as O’Leary did.

As the process setter in a negotiauction, you may be able to reduce this risk by minimizing delays between discussions with competitors. In the real world, entrepreneurs don’t typically negotiate, Shark Tank–style, in person with multiple bidders. Yet they do frequently drive up and down Sand Hill Road in Menlo Park or Route 128 outside Boston making the rounds of the big VC companies and, if they’re lucky, stirring up a bidding war. They certainly time such meetings carefully and stay attuned to the possibility of leaks.
Once you have two or more solid offers in hand, by all means try to play bidders against one another on issues where they can compete, such as price. But continue to avoid showing an open preference for a particular bidder on intangible issues such as rapport until you’re ready to make a commitment, lest other bidders find out and come to the assumption that they can’t compete.

3 game-changing strategies for bidders

Bidders often feel powerless in traditional auctions because their only source of leverage is to place aggressive bids. In negotiauctions, by contrast, bidders can gain an edge over the competition through “the relentless pursuit of game-changing moves,” according to Subramanian. Subramanian describes three such moves to change the game in his book Dealmaking: The New Strategy of Negotiauctions (W.W. Norton & Company, 2011):

1. Setup moves to establish terms of entry.

In a traditional auction, a seller (or sometimes a buyer) sets the rules of the game, and bidders follow them without complaint. In some instances, however, when your entry into a competitive situation has value, you shouldn’t give away that value for free. At the time that O’Leary made his offer to Majmundar, for example, his entry had enormous value because she had no other offers on the table. Clearly aware of this fact, O’Leary extracted a substantive concession in exchange for his bid: Get the cost of the product down to 56 cents. In other instances, wise negotiators extract process concessions: For example, exclusivity for a certain period of time or a commitment from the auctioneer for a single “best-and-final offer” round.

2. Rearranging moves to reconfigure the assets, parties, or both in a way that increases the value of the deal.

If you find yourself in a weakened position, a rearranging move can help unlock value. For example, two bidders in an auction might decide to pool their resources and submit a joint bid. Rearranging moves happen occasionally in the mergers-and-acquisitions world, where buyers can gain leverage when bidding on a prized company by joining forces. On Shark Tank, the sharks often make rearranging moves, trying to identify partners on the same side of the table. For example, Mavericks owner Cuban can put certain kinds of products into his basketball arena, and Greiner can get the same kinds of products on QVC. These sharks regularly join forces to unlock value, which then gives them more firepower against the other sharks.

3. Shutdown moves to prematurely cut off the competition.

While setup moves typically occur at the beginning of a negotiauction and rearranging moves occur while an auction is under way, shutdown moves can end the auction prematurely. Shutdown moves are a commonly used tool among the sophisticated VCs of Shark Tank. For example, Cuban will sometimes make an offer before the other sharks have heard enough about an entrepreneur’s product to know whether they want to bid—but he will condition his offer on the entrepreneur’s immediate acceptance. Analytically, Cuban is trying to short-circuit a competitive process with the other sharks through a shutdown move. Even though the entrepreneur would love to “shop” Cuban’s offer to the other sharks, the shutdown move often works because the entrepreneur wants to partner with Cuban, and the threat of his “short fuse” is highly credible.
In general, whether you are the process setter or a bidder in an auction that has features of a negotiation, don’t assume that the rules are set in stone. Instead, change the game by thinking about how you can influence the rules, parties, and assets to your advantage.

Negotiating in the Shadow of the Law

By following best practices, you can keep your dispute out of court—and turn it into a value-creating deal.

Consider the different procedures used to resolve two recent disputes involving sports superstars:

• In January, an Indianapolis Colts equipment manager complained that the New England Patriots had introduced underinflated footballs into their American Football Conference Championship Game to the possible benefit of Patriots quarterback Tom Brady. A controversial National Football League (NFL) investigation concluded, based on the evidence it collected, that it was “more probable than not” Patriots equipment personnel had deliberately broken rules and that Brady was “generally aware” the team’s staff had deflated footballs. The NFL reacted to the so-called Wells Report by suspending Brady without pay for the first four games of the 2015–2016 season and fining the Patriots $1 million, among other sanctions. The NFL responded to an appeal by the NFL Players Association on behalf of Brady by upholding his suspension; Brady vowed to keep fighting to clear his name. After the NFL and its players association were unable to reach a settlement in court, a federal judge overturned Brady’s suspension on the grounds that there was no “smoking gun” indicating he was aware that footballs had been deflated.

• Also in January, the New York Yankees reportedly began putting together a legal case to prevent record-breaking slugger Alex Rodriguez (A-Rod) from collecting the first in a series of bonuses he had negotiated with the team back in 2007 for meeting milestone home runs. Following Rodriguez’s confession in 2009 that he had used performance-enhancing drugs during his years with the Texas Rangers, the Yankees calculated that they would no longer be able to profit from Rodriguez’s milestones through the sale of commemorative memorabilia, which was to have been the funding source for A-Rod’s bonuses. With both sides eager to avoid a lengthy public arbitration process to settle their dispute, they were able to negotiate a creative deal in which Rodriguez agreed to drop his claim to the first bonus, $6 million, in exchange for a promise from the Yankees to donate $3.5 million to several charitable organizations. (For more detail, see the cover story of our October issue.)

Two different disputes, two very different means of resolving them. In the first dispute, the two sides were so far apart on matters of fact and principle that they had to leave their fate in the hands of a judge. Brady emerged victorious, though with some lingering reputational damage from the scandal. In the second, the parties were highly motivated to avoid a public adjudication process and worked hard to privately negotiate an agreement that met both sides’ interests.

When disputes arise, negotiators face the difficult question of whether to try to reach a settlement on their own or hand decision-making power over to a judge, a jury, or an arbitrator. Parties often benefit from settling their disputes before going to court, write Robert H. Mnookin, Scott R. Peppet, and Andrew S. Tulumello in their book Beyond Winning: Negotiating to Create Value in Deals and Disputes (Harvard University Press, 2000). Yet disputants and their lawyers typically overlook the potential costs of a legal battle. We review why that is so and how you can increase your odds of settling out of court, while also discussing instances when litigation might be preferable to negotiation.

The costs of going to court

The drawbacks of involving lawyers in your dispute and preparing for a lawsuit can be considerable.

1. Transaction costs.

Parties can incur significant transaction costs from a looming lawsuit, including legal fees and the loss of their precious time. In fact, one or both sides to a dispute may try to persuade the other party to make concessions by deliberately attempting to increase the other party’s transaction costs—for instance, by requesting mountains of documents and presenting long lists of questions that take many billable hours to answer. Your own legal team may also have financial incentives to drag out a discovery process to pad its fees—to your disadvantage. And when estimating likely legal fees, disputants often fail to factor in the time and expense of further litigation if they end up in court and the “loser” decides to appeal the court’s decision.

2. A lack of cooperation.

The widespread misconception that the best lawyers are aggressive and rigid, and never collaborative or accommodating can lead clients to hold back their legal team from exploring the type of creative (and money-saving) tradeoffs that the Yankees and Rodriguez put together. For lawyers, a client’s expectations of toughness can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. It’s not uncommon for both sides in a dispute to begin puffing up their positions and claims and to give the impression that they won’t back down under any circumstances. In this environment, parties unfortunately tend to perceive concessions and compromise as signs of weakness and vulnerability rather than as potential value-creating moves, write the authors of Beyond Winning.

3. Damaged relationships. Negotiators often fail to thoroughly consider the effects of legal action on their relationships with the other side and with other interested parties. “Disputes may strain relationships,” writes Harvard Business School professor Deepak Malhotra in a past Negotiation Briefings article, “but litigation tends to destroy them.” To take an obvious example, a divorcing couple that is able to negotiate a child-custody arrangement with the help of a neutral mediator may be more likely to build a productive post-divorce relationship, to the benefit of themselves and their children, than a couple that hires two “sharks” to attack each other’s character in court.

These drawbacks of litigation aside, it can sometimes be the best means of helping you meet a particular set of goals. The sidebar on the next page, “When Litigation Is the Best Option,” highlights legitimate reasons you might choose to litigate rather than negotiate.

For lawyer’s, a client’s expectations of toughness can become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Keeping it out of court

The following guidelines can help you reach creative, mutually beneficial resolutions to your disputes, with or without lawyers at the table.

1. Make sure the process is perceived to be fair.

The “Deflategate” case was fraught with accusations of conflicts of interest on the part of the NFL and its investigators. For example, one of the lawyers who worked on the league’s investigation, which was supposed to be impartial, had been involved in cross-examining Brady at his appeal hearing. Before tackling your dispute jointly, negotiate key elements of the process with your counterpart, such as how you will choose experts and whether lawyers will be involved in negotiations. Doing so will increase the odds that both sides will view the final outcome as unbiased and fair. In addition, you might suggest that you jointly hire a professional mediator to lead the settlement process instead of turning the process over to your lawyers.

2. Identify interests and tradeoffs.

Even when we’re determined to settle out of court, the win-lose format of a looming litigation can encourage us to view negotiation as a battle. Unfortunately, the desire to prove we’re right can distract us from pursuing our underlying interests. It can also propel us all the way up the courthouse steps if our adversary refuses to meet our needs.

Just as in business dealmaking, you can expand the pie of value in a dispute by opening up about your key interests and preferences, which can help you identify potential tradeoffs. Malhotra advises us to revisit the following questions often during the dispute-resolution process:

• What are my true underlying interests?

• How can I best achieve them?

• How much am I willing to pay just to be able to say that I won?

It’s also important to encourage the other party to open up about her interests and to keep those interests in mind as you negotiate. Rodriguez and the Yankees, for example, capitalized on their shared interest in helping others (and gaining positive publicity) by building charitable donations into their deal.

3. Insist on decision analysis.

Lawyers are often hesitant to quantify their clients’ odds of winning court cases, write Mnookin, Peppet, and Tulumello in Beyond Winning. Yet you need a thorough analysis of the risks and opportunities of litigation to make informed predictions and decisions about how to move forward. Any lawyers you hire should be well versed in decision-analysis tools such as decision trees and dependency diagrams and ready to use them to help improve the quality of your decisions.

4. Reduce discovery costs.

Disputants who are considering a lawsuit often become trapped in a lengthy and time-consuming discovery process that includes searching through reams of data and conducting depositions. You should be able to reduce these expenses by negotiating a low-cost exchange of essential information with your counterpart, write the Beyond Winning authors. When you can keep costs down, both sides win.

When Litigation is the Best Option

Though negotiation (whether conducted through lawyers, mediators, or on your own) should lead to better outcomes for disputants in most cases, litigation may be preferable in the following situations, writes Jeffrey R. Seul in a chapter in The Handbook of Dispute Resolution (Jossey-Bass, 2005):

  • An uncooperative counterpart. If your adversary stalls or refuses to negotiate in good faith, you might turn the case over to courts to ensure that it will eventually be resolved (though not necessarily in your favor). Court-ordered discovery will also legally compel a recalcitrant counterpart to supply information he might have held back during a dispute-resolution process.
  • A desire for openness and publicity. If you want to draw attention to your counterpart’s behavior or clear your name (as Brady did), you might choose to pursue a litigation process in which the outcome may be publicized, instead of private negotiations.
  • Deterring false charges. If you have been the repeated victim of false claims and opportunism, taking such cases to court may (if you win) deter others from targeting you in the future.
  • Settling legal questions. If deciding a dispute according to established legal norms or potentially setting new precedents is important to you, you might prefer to give decision-making authority to the courts.