Return to Why Aren't Mediation and Arbitration More Popular?
Loading ...Email to a Friend
Loading ... Loading ...
New Summer Programs
Taught by world-renowned professors, distinguished thought leaders and best-selling authors.
Stay Connected to PON
Articles & Insights
BATNA
- Business Negotiations
- Conflict Management
- Conflict Resolution
- Conflict Resolution and Negotiation Across Cultures
- “Confronting Evil” Panel Videos Now Available Online
- Conflict Resolution Lessons from the Home: How Conflict Management Skills Transform Discord Into Harmony
- Working with Your Agent – and Someone Else’s – In Negotiation
- Confronting Evil: Interdisciplinary Perspectives Conference underway
- Crisis Negotiations
- PON co-sponsored conference addresses the challenges of “Confronting Evil”
- Finding the Right Process in India
- The Fiscal Cliff and the Debt Ceiling: Program on Negotiation Chair Robert Mnookin Discusses Recent and Future Negotiations Between Congressional Republicans and the White House
- Robert Mnookin Joins Panel to Discuss the Fiscal Cliff Negotiations on NPR’s Forum
- BATNA for the Holidays? Program on Negotiation Co-Founders Bruce Patton and William Ury Discuss the ‘Fiscal Cliff’ with NPR
- Dealmaking
- Dispute Resolution
- International Negotiation
- Tips for Navigating Negotiations in China
- Negotiating in China: The Gold Rush Mentality
- PON panel discusses Track II Negotiations, Islands of Coordination and Unilateral Moves in the New Middle East
- Complexity Personified: International Standards Negotiations from a Microsoft Manager’s Perspective
- An International Negotiation for an All-American Brand
- Mediation
- Mediating Tragedy: Managing the Boston Victim’s Compensation Fund
- What’s Wrong with Traditional Arbitration?
- Hiring a Mediator: A Checklist
- Social Perceptions at the Crossroads: Why Sex (Still) Impacts the Perception and Evaluation of Other Status-Linked Identities
- Dispute Resolution Using Online Mediation
- Meeting Facilitation
- Negotiation Skills
- Negotiation Training
- Register Now for the Program on Negotiation’s Negotiation and Dispute Resolution Seminar!
- Negotiate Relationships
- Negotiation Training: What’s Special About Technology Negotiations?
- For Better Negotiation Training, Study the U.S. Government’s Mistakes
- Negotiating for Continuous Improvement: Use a Negotiation Preparation Worksheet
- Pedagogy
- Sales Negotiations
- Win Win
- Women and Negotiation
Mary Jarrett /
This article's authors seem to miss that contract/corporate lawyers are involved with many contracts, particularly the most complex, and in-house lawyers often provide clients with templates for the most common type of contract. So it is not only business people, but corporate lawyers, who don't know about the advantages of ADR provisions in business contracts (and employment agreements).
Michael Toebe /
Strong comments Mary, on which I agree. Corporate lawyers, thought certainly have heard, read or even seen the advantages of ADR but that's not their comfort zone. I also believe corporate lawyers are expected to be sledgehammers and thus fulfill that role.
Samuel Reslinger /
Thank you for this analysis. Although the two recommendations - ADR as default dispute resolution mechanisms and awareness of dispute likelihood - are fully relevant in general, I believe they might not be the prioritary rationale for businesses' insufficient demand for mediation and arbitration. We might have to consider that contracts are written by legal departments or law firms from more or less generic templates on one hand, while disputes are in numerous circumstances managed by management without involvement of legal counseling until late in the dispute process. When legal counseling gets involved, the situation is already entrenched, relationships are damaged, interests and egos are salient, the business sides demand a clear-cut solution, and the legal department/counseling is challenged to prove its expertise and value as a last resort savior able to get the best out of an intricate situation gone wild. For those reasons, official courts seem the best, most reassuring, and most effective - although not most efficient - solution. To avoid such a scenario, training the business side might be a solution: - Training managers on ADR procedures, for managers to know when and how to start one. - Getting business experts acquainted with ADR mechanisms and community, for business experts to believe that ADR community's business knowledge is relevant and ADR's methods are fair to let them understand objectively the issues and dilemmas businesses face. A periodic peer review by managers of their business issues could be also desirable, before those issues possibly transform into serious disputes. Appropriate facilitation by a professional member of the ADR community would be helpful.